Republican presidential nominee and former U.S. President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally at Grand Sierra Resort and Casino, Friday, October 11, 2024, in Reno, Nevada.
| Photo Credit: AP

Vowing to introduce a reciprocal tax if elected to power, former U.S. president Donald Trump has claimed that India imposes the highest tariffs on foreign products. But they do it with a smile, he added.

Also read: ‘India not an ‘abuser’ of tariffs, Trump’s claims unfair,’ says think tank GTRI

“Perhaps the most important element of my plan to make America extraordinarily wealthy again is reciprocity. It’s a word that’s very important in my plan because we generally don’t charge tariffs. I started that process, it was so great, with the vans and the small trucks, etc,” Mr. Trump said Thursday (October 10, 2024) in a major economic policy speech.

“We really don’t charge. China will charge us a 200 per cent tariff. Brazil is a big charger. The biggest charger of all is India,” the Republican presidential candidate said in Detroit.

But he softened the blow by heaping praise on Mr. Modi.

“India is a very big charger. We have a great relationship with India. I did. And especially the leader, Modi. He’s a great leader. Great man. Really is a great man. He’s brought it together. He’s done a great job,” he said.

“I mean, I think they probably charge more than, in many ways, China. But they do it with a smile. They do it… Sort of a nicer charge. They said thank you so much for purchasing from India,” he told members of the Detroit Economic Club.

Mr. Trump returned to the theme of import duties on Harley-Davidson motorcycles, and his meeting with the representatives of the American company during his previous term as president.

“I said how’s business? Good, good. What are the bad countries? Well, India is very tough. And they gave me some others. Why? Tariffs. I said what are they? And they said like 150 per cent, some massive amount,” Mr. Trump said.

He recalled the company representatives saying India wanted them to build a plant there.

Thursday’s remarks by Mr. Trump follow his praise for Mr. Modi earlier this week when he described Mr. Modi as “the nicest human being”.

“Modi, India. He’s a friend of mine. He’s great. Before him, they were replacing them every year. It’s very unstable. He came over. He’s a friend of mine. But on the outside, he looks like he’s your father. He’s the nicest, but he’s a total killer,” he had said.

Mr. Trump recalled the prime minister’s visit to Houston to attend the ‘Howdy Modi’ event during his tenure, and said, “It was beautiful. It’s like 80,000 people going crazy.” The Republican candidate had said he shared a “very good relationship” with Mr. Modi.

Recalling that there were a couple of occasions where somebody was “threatening” India, he said, “I told Modi let me help as I am very good with those people. To which he aggressively responded, ‘I will do it. I will do it. And I would do anything necessary. We have defeated them for hundreds of years.’ I said, ‘Whoa, what just happened there’.”

Republican presidential nominee and former U.S. President Donald Trump has labelled India the ‘tariff king’
| Photo Credit: Getty Images via AFP

Former U.S. President Donald Trump’s recent claim that India is an “abuser” of import tariffs is unfair as many nations including the U.S. protect their domestic industries by imposing high customs duties on certain products, think tank GTRI said on Friday.

It said that according to WTO’s World Tariff Profiles 2023, the U.S. also imposes high duties on items like dairy products (188%); fruits and vegetables (132%); coffee, tea, cocoa and spices (53%); cereals and food preparations (193%); oilseeds, fats and oils (164%); beverages and tobacco (150%); fish and fish products (35%); minerals and metals (187%); and chemicals (56%).

These numbers demonstrate that the U.S. also protects specific products of its economy with high tariffs, GTRI said in a report.

While India does impose high tariffs on certain items, including wines and automobiles, the Global Trade Research Initiative (GTRI) argued that these figures do not represent the overall tariff landscape.

“Trump’s argument singles out products with the highest tariffs while neglecting the average and trade-weighted tariffs that better represent India’s trade policy,” he said.

On September 17, Mr. Trump called India an “abuser” of import tariffs, a claim that echoed his October 2020 statement labelling India the “Tariff King”.

“While it is true that India imposes high duties on select products, Trump’s argument overlooks essential context, making his accusations unfair,” GTRI Founder Ajay Srivastava said, adding that many nations protect domestic industries by imposing significant tariffs on certain items.

India’s average tariff rate of 17% is higher than the US’s 3.3%, but similar to other major economies like South Korea (13.4%) and China (7.5%).

It also said that India has demonstrated its openness to free trade by removing customs duties for imports from FTA (free trade agreement) partners such as ASEAN (Association of South East Asian Nations), Japan, and South Korea.

“However, despite India’s willingness, the US has been reluctant to reduce tariffs through FTAs. This hesitation is clear in the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, where no tariff cuts were included, reflecting the US’s cautious approach,” Srivastava said.

If the U.S. is keen on zero tariff access into the Indian market, it should consider negotiating a free trade agreement with India, he added.

“While India needs serious tariff reforms, the label of ‘Tariff King’ does not hold up when compared to the tariff practices of the USA and other major economies,” he added.

Further, he said that Mr. Trump does not talk about average tariffs but singles out products with the highest tariffs charged by India.

“For example, on January 24, 2019, he said India charges a high 150% import tariff on the U.S. whiskey. Sure enough, India imposes high duties on many items. 150% on whiskey and wines 100-125% on automobiles. But India is not alone in doing so,” the GTRI said.

In reality, it said, most countries have high tariffs on a few goods such as Japan (457%), Korea (887%) and the U.S. (350%).

Explaining the realms behind these high duties, Srivastava said that most countries charge high tariffs on a few items with a reason.

“Japan may like to protect its rice farmers, the US its tobacco farmers and India its growing wine industry. Yet high tariff items do not represent the tariffs at which actual trade happens for most items. Average tariff and trade weightage tariff better represent a country’s tariff profile,” he added.