London:

A UK auction house has withdrawn a ‘Naga Human Skull’ from its lots for a live online sale on Wednesday following outcry in India over the issue.

The Swan auction house at Tetsworth in Oxfordshire had a series of skulls and other remains originating from around the world as part of ‘The Curious Collector Sale, Antiquarian Books, Manuscripts & Paintings. The ’19th Century Horned Naga Human Skull, Naga Tribe’ was slotted as Lot No. 64 and resulted in protests in Nagaland, led by Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio who sought the intervention of External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar to stop the hurtful sale.

“The news of the proposed auction of Naga human remains in the UK has been received by all sections in a negative manner as it is a highly emotional and sacred issue for our people. It has been a traditional custom of our people to give the highest respect and honour for the remains of the demised,” said Mr Rio in his letter.

He urged the minister to take up the matter with the High Commission of India in London so that steps are taken to ensure that the auction of the skull can be stopped after the Forum for Naga Reconciliation (FNR) raised concerns over the matter.

“This piece would be of particular interest to collectors with a focus on anthropology and tribal cultures,” reads the description of the auction lot, listed for an opening bid of GBP 2,100 (Rs 2.30 lakh approximately) with the auctioneer’s estimate expecting it to fetch as much as GBP 4,000 (Rs 4.39 lakh approximately). Its provenance is traced back to the collection of 19th century Belgian architect Francois Coppens.

The FNR asserted that the auction of the human remains contravenes Article 15 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), which says: “Indigenous Peoples have a right to the dignity and diversity of their cultures, traditions, histories and aspirations which shall be appropriately reflected in education and public information.” FNR then contacted the auction house directly to condemn the sale and to call for the object to be repatriated to Nagaland. The organisation is said to be one of many indigenous groups from across the world that is currently in dialogue with the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford about artefacts held in the museum’s collection.

Laura Van Broekhoven, director of the museum, was alerted by the BBC that human remains of Naga, Shuar, Dayak, Kota, Fon, Vili people and other communities in Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, Nigeria, Congo, and Benin were being auctioned.

“We are relieved to hear that the auction house has now removed all human remains from today’s sale and hope that the widespread comments and criticism from communities around the world have demonstrated that the sale of ancestral remains is offensive and unacceptable,” Professor Van Broekhoven said in a statement.

She added: “As an institution that stewards many human remains, we are conscious of the hurt and pain the removal of human remains has caused to communities across the globe, and to see human remains being put on auction is extremely painful and disrespectful to Indigenous People who consider their ancestors should come home to rest.

“It is highly unethical to auction the remains of ancestors of communities which were taken without the consent of those communities. This continues the harm that started during colonial times (where our museum has its foundations) and it leads to outrage and sadness among communities that today continue to live under very difficult circumstances.

“For many communities, it seems inconceivable that while ivory and bird eggs are protected from sale, their ancestral remains are not.” The Swan auction house has been approached for a comment.

(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)

Nagaland Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio.
| Photo Credit: ANI

A U.K. auction house has withdrawn a ‘Naga Human Skull’ from its lots for a live online sale on Wednesday (October 9, 2024) following outcry in India over the issue.

The Swan auction house at Tetsworth in Oxfordshire had a series of skulls and other remains originating from around the world as part of ‘The Curious Collector Sale, Antiquarian Books, Manuscripts & Paintings. The ‘19th Century Horned Naga Human Skull, Naga Tribe’ was slotted as Lot No. 64 and resulted in protests in Nagaland, led by Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio who sought the intervention of External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar to stop the hurtful sale.

“The news of the proposed auction of Naga human remains in the U.K. has been received by all sections in a negative manner as it is a highly emotional and sacred issue for our people. It has been a traditional custom of our people to give the highest respect and honour for the remains of the demised,” said Mr. Rio in his letter.

He urged the Minister to take up the matter with the High Commission of India in London so that steps are taken to ensure that the auction of the skull can be stopped after the Forum for Naga Reconciliation (FNR) raised concerns over the matter.

“This piece would be of particular interest to collectors with a focus on anthropology and tribal cultures,” reads the description of the auction lot, listed for an opening bid of GBP 2,100 (₹23 lakh approximately) with the auctioneer’s estimate expecting it to fetch as much as GBP 4,000 (₹43 lakh approximately).

Its provenance is traced back to the collection of 19th century Belgian architect Francois Coppens.

The FNR asserted that the auction of the human remains contravenes Article 15 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), which says: “Indigenous Peoples have a right to the dignity and diversity of their cultures, traditions, histories and aspirations which shall be appropriately reflected in education and public information.” FNR then contacted the auction house directly to condemn the sale and to call for the object to be repatriated to Nagaland. The organisation is one of many indigenous groups from across the world that is currently in dialogue with the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford about artefacts held in the museum’s collection.

Laura Van Broekhoven, director of the museum, told the BBC she was “outraged” at some of these items going up for auction.

“The fact these objects were taken is really painful, and the fact that they were being put on sale is really disrespectful and inconsiderate,” said Broekhoven.

“We’re conscious that the remains would have been collected in the 19th and 20th centuries, but for them to be on sale in 2024 was quite shocking,” she said.

The Swan auction house has been approached for a comment.

Kohima:

Nagaland Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio on Tuesday sought the intervention of the Centre to stop a proposed auction of a “19th century horned Naga human skull” in the United Kingdom scheduled for Wednesday.

The auctioning of human remains deeply hurts the sentiments of the people, and it is an act of dehumanization and is considered as continued colonial violence upon the Naga people, Neiphiu Rio said in a letter to External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar.

“The news of the proposed auction of Naga human remains in the UK has been received by all sections in a negative manner as it is a highly emotional and sacred issue for our people. It has been a traditional custom of our people to give the highest respect and honour for the remains of the demised,” said Neiphiu Rio.

The human remains of any dead person belong to their people and land, he said in the letter.

The Chief Minister urged S Jaishankar to take up this matter with the Indian High Commission in the UK so that steps are taken to ensure that the auction of the Naga human remains is stopped.

Rio said he was informed about the proposed auction by Forum for Naga Reconciliation (FNR), an organisation of the Nagas.

The FNR informed the Chief Minister that a “19th century horned Naga human skull” is part of an auction by an firm in the United Kingdom.

The value of the Naga human remains is estimated at 3,500 to 4,000 UK pounds.

The Naga ancestral human skull is part of an auction titled “The curious collector sale” and is catalogued alongside antiquarian books, manuscripts, paintings, jewellery, ceramics and furniture, the FNR informed Rio.

The FNR asserted that the auction of the human remains contravenes Article 15 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) which says: “Indigenous Peoples have a right to the dignity and diversity of their cultures, traditions, histories and aspirations which shall be appropriately reflected in education and public information.” 

(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)